Thursday, April 7, 2016

OT canon



The canon of what Christians call the Old Testament and what Jews call the Hebrew Bible or TaNaKh has an interesting history. It may be commonly accepted that the Jewish canon has 24 books divided into three sections—Torah, Nevi'im (Prophets), and Ketuvim (Writings)—but this has not always been the case. Indeed, Jews have even had 22-book, 3-division and also 4-division canons during their history. The establishment of the 24-book, tripartite canon is a relatively new development. Christians may feel that their 39-book, quadripartite canon is inferior or less valid than the tripartite canon, but as this analysis of early canon lists shows, the quadripartite was a viable alternative to the tripartite canon for many years until the Jewish community established the tripartite canon as normative.

We will first look at the canon list of the church father Origen who lived in the third century Common Era (two hundred years after Christ). His canon is interesting because it has 22 books, not 24, and appears to support a quadripartite division rather than a tripartite, although that is not clear because he does not state the divisions himself. Another peculiarity of Origen's canon is that he only lists 21 books, even though he says there are 22 books. From comparison with the traditional canon, one realizes that Origen forgot to enumerate the single book of the Twelve Minor Prophets. (Although it may be possible that Origen intended to count Maccabees as the 22nd book, which, however, he states is outside of the rest of the books.)

Origen's Canon c. 240 CE/A.D.

From the account of Eusebius in his Ecclesiastical History, vi. 25, copied from Michael D. Marlowe's Bible-Researcher.com.


τὸν μέν γε πρῶτον ἐξηγούμενος Ψαλμόν, ἔκθεσιν πεποίηται τοῦ τῶν ἱερῶν γραφῶν τῆς παλαιᾶς διαθήκης καταλόγου, ὧδέ πως γράφων κατὰ λέξιν· «οὐκ ἀγνοητέον δ' εἶναι τὰς ἐνδιαθήκους βίβλους, ὡς Ἑβραῖοι παραδιδόασιν, δύο καὶ εἴκοσι, ὅσος ἀριθμὸς τῶν παρ' αὐτοῖς στοιχείων ἐστίν». εἶτα μετά τινα ἐπιφέρει λέγων· «εἰσὶν δὲ αἱ εἴκοσι δύο βίβλοι καθ' Ἑβραίους αἵδε·
  1. ἡ παρ' ἡμῖν Γένεσις ἐπιγεγραμμένη, παρὰ δ' Ἑβραίοις ἀπὸ τῆς ἀρχῆς τῆς βίβλου Βρησιθ, ὅπερ ἐστὶν «ἐν ἀρχῆι»·
  2. Ἔξοδος, Ουελλεσμωθ, ὅπερ ἐστὶν «ταῦτα τὰ ὀνόματα»·
  3. Λευιτικόν, Ουϊκρα, «καὶ ἐκάλεσεν»·
  4. Ἀριθμοί, Αμμεσφεκωδειμ·
  5. Δευτερονόμιον, Ελλεαδδεβαρειμ, «οὗτοι οἱ λόγοι»·
  6. Ἰησοῦς υἱὸς Ναυῆ, Ιωσουεβεννουν·
  7. Κριταί, Ῥούθ, παρ' αὐτοῖς ἐν ἑνί, Σωφτειμ·
  8. Βασιλειῶν αʹ βʹ, παρ' αὐτοῖς ἕν, Σαμουὴλ, «ὁ θεόκλητος»·
  9. Βασιλειῶν γʹ δʹ ἐν ἑνί, Ουαμμελχδαυιδ, ὅπερ ἐστὶν «βασιλεία Δαυίδ»·
  10. Παραλειπομένων αʹ βʹ ἐν ἑνί, Δαβρηϊαμειν, ὅπερ ἐστὶν «λόγοι ἡμερῶν»·
  11. Ἔζρας αʹ βʹ ἐν ἑνί, Εζρα, ὅ ἐστιν «βοηθός»·
  12. βίβλος Ψαλμῶν, Σφαρθελλειμ·
  13. Σολομῶνος παροιμίαι, Μελωθ·
  14. Ἐκκλησιαστής, Κωελθ·
  15. Ἆισμα ἀισμάτων οὐ γάρ, ὡς ὑπολαμβάνουσίν τινες, Ἄισματα ἀισμάτων, Σιρασσιρειμ·
  16. Ἡσαΐας, Ιεσσια·
  17. Ἱερεμίας σὺν Θρήνοις καὶ τῆι Ἐπιστολῆι ἐν ἑνί, Ιερεμια·
  18. Δανιήλ, Δανιηλ·
  19. Ἰεζεκιήλ, Ιεζεκιηλ·
  20. Ἰώβ, Ιωβ·
  21. Ἐσθήρ Εσθηρ.
ἔξω δὲ τούτων ἐστὶ τὰ Μακκαβαϊκά, ἅπερ ἐπιγέγραπται Σαρβηθσαβαναιελ». ταῦτα μὲν οὖν ἐν τῶι προειρημένωι τίθησι συγγράμματι·

When expounding the first Psalm he gives a catalog of the Sacred Scriptures of the Old Testament as follows: It should be stated that the canonical books, as the Hebrews have handed them down, are twenty-two, corresponding with the number of their letters. Farther on he says: The twenty-two books of the Hebrews are the following:
  1. That which is called by us Genesis, but by the Hebrews, from the beginning of the book, Breshith, which means in the beginning;
  2. Exodus, Welesmoth, that is, these are the names;
  3. Leviticus, Wikra, and he called;
  4. Numbers, Ammesfekodeim;
  5. Deuteronomy, Eleaddebareim these are the words;
  6. Joshua the son of Nun, Iosoue ben Noun;
  7. Judges and Ruth, among them in one book, Saphateim;
  8. the first and second of Kings, among them one, Samoel, that is, the called of God;
  9. the third and fourth of Kings in one, Wammelch David, that is, the kingdom of David;
  10. of the Chronicles, the first and second in one, Dabreiamein, that is, records of days;
  11. Esdras, first and second in one, Ezra, that is, an assistant;
  12. the book of Psalms, Sfarthelleim;
  13. the Proverbs of Solomon, Meloth;
  14. Ecclesiastes, Koelth;
  15. the Song of Songs (not, as some suppose, Songs of Songs), Sir Hassirim;
  16. Isaiah, Iessia;
  17. Jeremiah, with Lamentations and the Epistle in one, Ieremia;
  18. Daniel, Daniel;
  19. Ezekiel, Iezekiel;
  20. Job, Iob;
  21. Esther, Esther.
And outside of these there are the Maccabees, which are entitled Sarbeth Sabanaiel.
He gives these in the above-mentioned work.

If we were to divide Origen's canon, we might count books 1–5 as Torah, books 6–11 as History, books 12–15 as Wisdom, and books 16–19 as Prophets. However, that leaves books 20 and 21 (Job and Esther) without a category. A quadripartite division seems to be the only way to subdivide Origen's canon, as a tripartite division would have to include the Prophets with the Wisdom/Writings books, which seems unprecedented throughout history. However, a tripartite understanding of Origen's canon would give Job and Esther a category. A tripartite division would count 1–5 as Torah, 6–11 as History, and 12–21 as Wisdom/Prophets/Writings. Nevertheless, such a tripartite understanding is not identical to Judaism's modern-day canon and therefore represents an alternate canon. It is possible that Origen's canon reflects a two-part (bipartite) canon, consisting of Torah, and then everything else.

Let us see if a comparison with other canon lists can help us.

Another church father, Jerome, wrote a canon list which is more complete than Origen's. The reason I chose these two church fathers, Origen and Jerome, is that both of these church fathers were the only ones to study Hebrew. Since we are discussing the canon of a Hebrew text, I am limiting my search to those church fathers who studied Hebrew and therefore were able to learn the canon with local Jews that they met. If Jerome had not learned Hebrew, he would not have translated the Latin Vulgate from Hebrew and would not have known that almost none of the books of the Deuterocanon/Apocrypha have any Hebrew text behind them—most of the Apocryphal books were written in Greek, not Hebrew.

Jerome lived a century after Origen and almost four hundred years after Christ.

Jerome's Preface to the Books of the Kings, Circa A.D. 391, copied from Michael D. Marlowe's Bible-Researcher.com


Viginti et duas esse litteras apud Hebraeos, Syrorum quoque et Chaldeorum lingua testatur, quae hebraeae magna ex parte confinis est; nam et ipsi viginti duo elementa habent eodem sono, sed diversis caracteribus. Samaritani etiam Pentateuchum Mosi totidem litteris scriptitant, figuris tantum et apicibus discrepantes. Certumque est Ezram scribam legisque doctorem post captam Hierosolymam et instaurationem templi sub Zorobabel alias litteras repperisse, quibus nunc utimur, cum ad illud usque tempus idem Samaritanorum et Hebraeorum caracteres fuerint. In libro quoque Numerorum haec eadem supputatio sub Levitarum ac sacerdotum censu mystice ostenditur. Et nomen Domini tetragrammaton in quibusdam graecis voluminibus usque hodie antiquis expressum litteris invenimus. Sed et psalmi tricesimus sextus, et centesimus decimus, et centesimus undecimus, et centesimus octavus decimus, et centesimus quadragesimus quartus, quamquam diverso scribantur metro, tamen eiusdem numeri texuntur alfabeto. Et Hieremiae Lamentationes et oratio eius, Salomonis quoque in fine Proverbia ab eo loco in quo ait: «Mulierem fortem quis inveniet», hisdem alfabetis vel incisionibus supputantur. Porro quinque litterae duplices apud eos sunt: chaph, mem, nun, phe, sade; aliter enim per has scribunt principia medietatesque verborum, aliter fines. Unde et quinque a plerisque libri duplices aestimantur: Samuhel, Malachim, Dabreiamin, Ezras, Hieremias cum Cinoth, id est Lamentationibus suis. Quomodo igitur viginti duo elementa sunt, per quae scribimus hebraice omne quod loquimur, et eorum initiis vox humana conprehenditur, ita viginti duo volumina supputantur, quibus quasi litteris et exordiis, in Dei doctrina, tenera adhuc et lactans viri iusti eruditur infantia.

That the Hebrews have twenty-two letters is testified also by the Syrian and Chaldean languages, which for the most part correspond to the Hebrew; for they have twenty-two elementary sounds which are pronounced the same way, but are differently written. The Samaritans also write the Pentateuch of Moses with just the same number of letters, differing only in the shape and points of the letters. And it is certain that Esdras, the scribe and teacher of the law, after the capture of Jerusalem and the restoration of the temple by Zerubbabel, invented other letters which we now use, for up to that time the Samaritan and Hebrew characters were the same. In the book of Numbers, moreover, where we have the census of the Levites and priests [Num. 3:39], the same total is presented mystically. And we find the four-lettered name of the Lord [tetragrammaton] in certain Greek books written to this day in the ancient characters. The thirty-seventh Psalm, moreover, the one hundred and eleventh, the one hundred and twelfth, the one hundred and nineteenth, and the one hundred and forty-fifth, although they are written in different metres, are all composed [as acrostics] according to an alphabet of the same number of letters. The Lamentations of Jeremiah, and his Prayer, the Proverbs of Solomon also, towards the end, from the place where we read Who will find a steadfast woman? are instances of the same number of letters forming the division into sections. Furthermore, five are double letters, viz., Caph, Mem, Nun, Phe, Sade, for at the beginning and in the middle of words they are written one way, and at the end another way. Whence it happens that, by most people, five of the books are reckoned as double, viz., Samuel, Kings, Chronicles, Ezra, and Jeremiah with Kinoth, i.e., his Lamentations. As, then, there are twenty-two elementary characters by means of which we write in Hebrew all we say, and the human voice is comprehended within their limits, so we reckon twenty-two books, by which, as by the alphabet of the doctrine of God, a righteous man is instructed in tender infancy, and, as it were, while still at the breast.

Primus apud eos liber vocatur Bresith, quem nos Genesim dicimus; secundus Hellesmoth, qui Exodus appellatur; tertius Vaiecra, id est Leviticus; quartus Vaiedabber, quem Numeros vocamus; quintus Addabarim, qui Deuteronomium praenotatur. Hii sunt quinque libri Mosi, quos proprie Thorath, id est Legem appellant.
The first of these books is called Bresith, to which we give the name Genesis. The second, Elle Smoth, which bears the name Exodus; the third, Vaiecra, that is Leviticus; the fourth, Vaiedabber, which we call Numbers; the fifth, Elle Addabarim, which is entitled Deuteronomy. These are the five books of Moses, which they properly call Thorath, that is, Law.
Secundum Prophetarum ordinem faciunt, et incipiunt ab Iesu filio Nave, qui apud eos Iosue Bennum dicitur. Deinde subtexunt Sopthim, id est Iudicum librum; et in eundem conpingunt Ruth, quia in diebus Iudicum facta narratur historia. Tertius sequitur Samuhel, quem nos Regnorum primum et secundum dicimus. Quartus Malachim, id est Regum, qui tertio et quarto Regnorum volumine continetur; meliusque multo est Malachim, id est Regum, quam Malachoth, id est Regnorum dicere, non enim multarum gentium regna describit, sed unius israhelitici populi qui tribubus duodecim continetur. Quintus est Esaias, sextus Hieremias, septimus Hiezecihel, octavus liber duodecim Prophetarum, qui apud illos vocatur Thareasra. The second class is composed of the Prophets, and they begin with Jesus the son of Nave, which among them is called Iosue ben Nun. Next in the series is Sophtim, that is the book of Judges; and in the same book they include Ruth, because the events narrated occurred in the days of the Judges. Then comes Samuel, which we call First and Second Kings. The fourth is Malachim, that is, Kings, which is contained in the third and fourth volumes of Kings. And it is far better to say Malachim, that is Kings, than Malachoth, that is Kingdoms. For the author does not describe the Kingdoms of many nations, but that of one people, the people of Israel, which is comprised in the twelve tribes. The fifth is Isaiah; the sixth, Jeremiah; the seventh, Ezekiel; and the eighth is the book of the Twelve Prophets, which is called among them Thare Asra.
Tertius ordo αγιογραφα possidet, et primus liber incipit ab Iob, secundus a David, quem quinque incisionibus et uno Psalmorum volumine conprehendunt. Tertius est Salomon, tres libros habens: Proverbia, quae illi Parabolas, id est Masaloth appellant, et Ecclesiasten, id est Accoeleth, et Canticum canticorum, quem titulo Sirassirim praenotant. Sextus est Danihel, septimus Dabreiamin, id est Verba dierum, quod significantius χρονικον totius divinae historiae possumus appellare, qui liber apud nos Paralipomenon primus et secundus scribitur; octavus Ezras, qui et ipse similiter apud Graecos et Latinos in duos libros divisus est, nonus Hester. To the third class belong the Hagiographa, of which the first book begins with Job; the second with David, whose writings they divide into five parts and comprise in one volume of Psalms. The third is Solomon, in three books: Proverbs, which they call Parables, that is Masaloth; Ecclesiastes, that is Coeleth; and the Song of Songs, which they denote by the title Sirassirim. The sixth is Daniel; the seventh, Dabre Aiamim, that is, Words of Days, which we may more descriptively call a chronicle of the whole of the sacred history, the book that amongst us is called First and Second Paralipomenon [Chronicles]. The eighth is Ezra, which itself is likewise divided amongst Greeks and Latins into two books; the ninth is Esther.
Atque ita fiunt pariter veteris legis libri viginti duo, id est Mosi quinque, Prophetarum octo, Agiograforum novem. Quamquam nonnulli Ruth et Cinoth inter Agiografa scriptitent et libros hos in suo putent numero supputandos, ac per hoc esse priscae legis libros viginti quattuor, quos sub numero viginti quattuor seniorum Apocalypsis Iohannis inducit adorantes Agnum et coronas suas prostratis vultibus offerentes, stantibus coram quattuor animalibus oculatis retro et ante, id est et in praeteritum et in futurum, et indefessa voce clamantibus: «Sanctus, sanctus, sanctus Dominus Deus omnipotens, qui erat et qui est et qui futurus est». And so there are also twenty-two books of the Old Law; that is, five of Moses, eight of the prophets, nine of the Hagiographa, though some include Ruth and Kinoth (Lamentations) amongst the Hagiographa, and think that these books ought to be reckoned separately; we should thus have twenty-four books of the ancient Law. And these the Apocalypse of John represents by the twenty-four elders, who adore the Lamb and offer their crowns with lowered visage, while in their presence stand the four living creatures with eyes before and behind, that is, looking to the past and the future, and with unwearied voice crying, Holy, Holy, Holy, Lord God Almighty, who was and is and will be.

Let us compare the canons of Origen and Jerome.

Origen's Canon*Jerome's Canon

  1. Genesis
  2. Exodus
  3. Leviticus
  4. Numbers
  5. Deuteronomy
  6. Joshua
  7. Judges + Ruth
  8. 1, 2 Samuel
  9. 1, 2 Kings
  10. 1, 2 Chronicles
  11. Ezra—Nehemiah
  12. Psalms
  13. Proverbs of Solomon
  14. Ecclesiastes
  15. the Song of Songs
  16. Isaiah
  17. Jeremiah–Lamentations—Baruch
  18. Daniel
  19. Ezekiel
  20. Job
  21. Esther
  22. ? (?Maccabees?)
*missing the Twelve

  1. Torah
    1. Genesis
    2. Exodus
    3. Leviticus
    4. Numbers
    5. Deuteronomy
  2. Prophets
    1. Joshua
    2. Judges + Ruth*
    3. 1, 2 Samuel
    4. 1, 2 Kings
    5. Isaiah
    6. Jeremiah + Lamentations*
    7. Ezekiel
    8. The Twelve
  3. Hagiographa = Holy Writings
    1. Job
    2. Psalms of David
    3. Proverbs of Solomon
    4. Ecclesiastes
    5. Song of Songs
    6. Daniel
    7. 1, 2 Chronicles
    8. Ezra—Nehemiah
    9. Esther
total = 22

*some put Lamentations and Ruth in Hagiographa = 24 books

It should be noted that Jerome's canon is exactly the same as today's Jewish 24-book tripartite canon, especially when one places Ruth and Lamentations in the Hagiographa. Origen's canon seems to be a melding of the Greek quadripartite canon and the Hebrew tripartite canon.

The first-century Jewish writer Josephus mentions a canon in his works but does not enumerate the books, so we are left to guess the order.

Josephus, Against Apion, I.8, copied from University of Chicago, translated by William Whiston.

For we have not an innumerable multitude of books among us, disagreeing from, and contradicting one another: [as the Greeks have:] but only twenty-two books: which contain the records of all the past times: which are justly believed to be divine. And of them five belong to Moses: which contain his laws, and the traditions of the origin of mankind, till his death. This interval of time was little short of three thousand years. But as to the time from the death of Moses, till the reign of Artaxerxes, King of Persia, who reigned after Xerxes, the Prophets, who were after Moses, wrote down what was done in their times, in thirteen books. The remaining four books contain hymns to God; and precepts for the conduct of human life. ’Tis true, our history hath been written since Artaxerxes very particularly; but hath not been esteemed of the like authority with the former by our forefathers; because there hath not been an exact succession of Prophets since that time. And how firmly we have given credit to these books of our own nation, is evident by what we do. For during so many ages as have already passed, no one has been so bold, as either to add any thing to them; to take any thing from them; or to make any change in them. But it is become natural to all Jews, immediately, and from their very birth, to esteem these books to contain divine doctrines; and to persist in them: and, if occasion be, willingly to die for them. For ’tis no new thing for our captives, many of them in number, and frequently in time, to be seen to endure wracks, and deaths of all kinds, upon the theatres; that they may not be obliged to say one word against our laws, and the records that contain them. Whereas there are none at all among the Greeks who would undergo the least harm on that account: no nor in case all the writings that are among them were to be destroyed. For they take them to be such discourses as are framed agreeably to the inclinations of those that write them. And they have justly the same opinion of the elder writers: since they see some of the present generation bold enough to write about such affairs, wherein they were not present; nor had concern enough to inform themselves about them from those that knew them. Examples of which may be had in this late war of ours: where some persons have written histories, and published them, without having been in the places concerned; or having been near them when the actions were done: but these men put a few things together, by hearsay; and insolently abuse the world; and call these writings by the name of Histories.

As you can see, Josephus states that the Jews held to a 22-book canon, of which 5 were Torah, 13 comprised the Prophets, or History books, and the remaining 4 were Writings. By comparing the various canon lists, we can deduce what Josephus' canon consisted of. Obviously, the Torah is the same in all of them. Since it was a 22-book canon, we know that two books were combined, namely Ruth with Judges, and Lamentations with Jeremiah, instead of being in the Writings. Since there are only 4 in the Writings, we will assume that Chronicles, Ezra—Nehemiah, and Daniel will assume their alternate position in the Prophets, not the Writings. Since Josephus says the Writings is composed of hymns to God and precepts for human conduct, we can assume that his Writings is mainly Wisdom books, namely, Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs (or Job). I am leaning towards the three Solomonic works being together in the Writings, and Job being in the Prophets. For the rest of the books, we can start placing them in their hypothetical order:


  1. Torah
    1. Genesis
    2. Exodus
    3. Leviticus
    4. Numbers
    5. Deuteronomy
  2. Prophets
    1. Joshua
    2. Judges + Ruth
    3. 1, 2 Samuel
    4. 1, 2 Kings
    5. 1, 2 Chronicles
    6. Ezra—Nehemiah
    7. Esther
    8. Job
    9. Isaiah
    10. Jeremiah + Lamentations
    11. Daniel
    12. Ezekiel
    13. The Twelve
  3. Hagiographa = Holy Writings
    1. Psalms of David
    2. Proverbs of Solomon
    3. Ecclesiastes
    4. Song of Songs

It is interesting to see the various canon lists because it shows how the ordering of the canon has changed over the years. Note that except for Origen's mention of Maccabees as outside the rest, all the books are the same, it's only the order that is different. In Josephus, we see a sort of hybrid canon—it is tripartite and has 22 books, but its categorization of those books bears more resemblance to the quadripartite system. Origen's canon is a representative of a 22-book quadripartite system, although it is hard to tell exactly where his boundaries are between the subdivisions. Finally, Jerome's canon is the precursor to the modern Jewish Tanakh canon. Therefore, we know that by Jerome's day, a 22-book (or 24-book, depending on how you count Ruth and Lamentations) tripartite system was in the process of normalization. For the 1600 years since Jerome's day, Jews have maintained their Hebrew canon, deciding to count Ruth and Lamentations as Writings.

Near that time, Judaism codified the tripartite system of its Scriptures in order to differentiate itself from Christianity. (Or Christianity might have differentiated itself from Judaism.) Even though that is what Judaism decided on, they could have just as easily decided on the quadripartite canon, with Chronicles, Ezra–Nehemiah, Job, Esther, and Daniel finding their place earlier in the biblical narrative, as in the modern-day Christian canon. It is unfortunate that Judaism has latched on to the tripartite system and that Christianity has latched onto the quadripartite system, when in fact, both canons were authentically Jewish. The quadripartite system probably arose among Greek-speaking Jews and is divided into a more straightforward, chronologically intact order. The tripartite system separates the books from their narrative order and places them in a thematic or genre-oriented order. It is possible that the tripartite system is more ancient and that it captures the order of the admissions of the books into the canon.

As the Jewish Study Bible states, The time of the origin of the name Tanakh is not clear. Rabbinic texts recognize a tripartite canon, where the names we know of, Torah, Neviʾim and Kethuvim, are used for each part of the canon (2073).

It continues,

The origin of the tripartite canon has been a topic of recent dispute, with several scholars suggesting that a two-part canon, the Torah and other works, was the original form, and that only later was it divided into three parts. It is more likely, however, that the tripartite canon is primary, and evidence for it appears in such sources as the prologue to the Wisdom of Jesus ben Sirach, which says that many great teachings have been given to us through the Law and the Prophets and the others (or, other books) that followed them and Luke 24.44, which refers to the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms, and in parallel expressions in the Dead Sea Scrolls. The tripartite canon likely reflects the gradual nature of the canonization process, with Neviʾim canonized before Kethuvim. This would explain why the Kethuvim contain the book of the prophet Daniel (dating from the 2nd century BCE), and several late historical books, such as Ezra-Nehemiah and Chronicles, which would seem more appropriately to belong with similar works such as Joshua and Kings. The tripartite canon most likely suggests, therefore, that Torah was canonized in the Persian period, followed by the canonization of the Neviʾim in the late Persian or early Greek period, while the Kethuvim were canonized last, around the time of the destruction of the Second Temple (70 CE). (page 2074)

I disagree with the later dating for canonization (I would move it back several centuries), but I agree with the insights discussed in this paragraph. The information continues to discuss the quadripartite canon:


The tripartite order is not the only one known in antiquity, nor is the number of twenty-four books the only number mentioned in ancient Jewish sources. Josephus, the Jewish historian of the 1st century CE, refers to twenty-two biblical books (Against Apion 1.42). It is not clear if he simply had a smaller canon or if, instead, his canon had the texts in a different order, combined in different ways. Some traditions put Ruth after Judges and Lamentations after Jeremiah, treating these smaller books as appendices to the ones they follow, rather than independent works. Such an arrangement of would yield twenty-two books, a number which conveniently corresponds to the number of letters in the Hebrew alphabet; some early Christian sources also cite this as the number of books in the Bible. … According to this originally Jewish tradition, mentioned in some early church fathers and reflected in the arrangement of the earliest comprehensive Septuagint manuscripts (4th century CE), the Hebrew Bible is divided into four parts: Torah, Histories, Poetical and Wisdom books, and Prophets. This order continues to be used by Christians in their organization of the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) materials. Older scholarship spoke of this four-part, twenty-two book arrangement as the Alexandrian canon, in contrast to the tripartite, twenty-four book Palestinian canon, but scholars now recognize that such a clear dichotomy never existed and therefore avoid the use of those terms. (page 2074)

Whichever canon is original or current, the canon should not be used as a polemic against other faith communities or as a hammer to beat people with. As we can see, there are historical reasons why certain orderings and categorizations took place. We should not disparage other's canons by claiming that ours is more authentic (e.g., the Jewish 24-book or the Christian four-part canon). As we saw, there were many variations and re-arrangements and it took many years for the canon to normalize into its present forms.

What follows is a chart of the books of the canon, with their Hebrew names, English names, and the names that Origen and Jerome provided for them. The list follows Origen's order. It is interesting to see the linguistic changes from Hebrew to Greek to Latin and then the English names we have today.

English Name Hebrew Name Hebrew Transliteration Origen's Name Jerome's Name
Genesis
בְּרֵאשִׁית
Bĕrēšīt̲ (B'reshith) Brēsith Bresith
Exodus
וְאֵלֶּה שְׁמוֹת
Wĕʾēlleh Šĕmôt̲ (W'elleh Shemoth) Ouellesmōth Hellesmoth
Leviticus
וַיִּקְרָא
Wayyiqrāʾ Ouikra Vaiecra
Numbers
בְּמִדְבַּר
Bemidbar Ammesfekōdeim Vaiedabber
Deuteronomy
אֵלֶּה הַדְּבָרִים
ʾēlleh haddb̲ārîm (W'elleh hadvarim) Elleaddebareim Addabarim
Joshua
יְהוֹשֻׁעַ
Yehōshuʿa Yōsoue-ben-noun Iosue Bennun
Judges
Ruth
שֹֽׁפְטִים
רוּת
Shōphtim
Ruth
Sōphteim
Routh
Sopthim
Ruth
I and II Samuel
שְׁמוּאֵל
Shemuʾēl Somouēl Samuhel
I and II Kings
מְּלָכִים
Melakim Ουαμμελχδαυιδ
Wamellech Dawid
Melachim
I and II Chronicles
דִּבְרֵי הַיָּמִים
Divrei hayamim Δαβρηϊαμειν
Dabrēyamein
Dabreiamin
Ezra + Nehemiah
עֶזְרָא
נְחֶמְיָה
ʿEzraʾ
Nĕḥemyāh
Ezra Ezras
Psalms
תְּהִלִּים
Tĕhillîm Sfarthelleim (contraction of sefer tehillim, book of psalms) Psalms of David
Proverbs
מִשְׁלֵי
MišlêMishlei Melōth Masaloth (parables)
Ecclesiastes
קֹהֶלֶת
Qōheleṯ Kōelth Coeleth
The Song of Songs
שִׁיר הַשִּׁירִים
Shir haShirim Sirassireim Sirassirim
Isaiah
יְשַׁעְיָהוּ
Yĕshaʿyāhû Iessia Esaias
Jeremiah + Lamentations
יִרְמְיָהוּ
אֵיכָה
Yirmĕyāhû
ʾEicāh
Ieremia Hieremias + Kinoth
Daniel
דָּנִיֵּאל
Dāniyyēʾl Daniēl Danihel
Ezekiel
יְחֶזְקֵאל
Yĕḥezqēʾl Iezekiēl Hiezecihel
The Twelve (Minor Prophets)
תרי עשר
Trei ʿAsar N/A Thareasra
Job
אִיּוֹב
ʾIyyôv Iōb Iob
Esther
אֶסְתֵּר
ʾEstēr Esthēr Hester

Sources:

Brettler, Marc Zvi. The Canonization of the Bible. In The Jewish Study Bible: Jewish Publication Society Tanakh Translation, edited by Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler, 2072-2077. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004.

Thursday, March 24, 2016

Of Kings and Prophets Episode 2 review

In the second episode of the biblical saga Of Kings and Prophets, much goes awry—Rizpah betrays King Saul to King Achish, Eshbaal hires an assassin to kill the prophet Samuel, and tensions rise as Saul realizes that the people no longer see him as a valid king.

And King Saul's wife, Ahinoam, seduces David.

Yeah...

Any people of faith who viewed the first episode and expected an uplifting, biblical show should have known better. And all of us who continued watching to the second episode, you have no excuse. That includes me.

I was repulsed by the depiction of Ahinoam seducing David—not that it was graphic, in fact, nothing is shown at all, except them kissing and then it skips ahead to him walking out of the chamber tightening his belt. It is depicted through suggestion. —But the idea that David would sleep with King Saul's wife and queen was revolting, adulterous, and a defiance of Torah. (Not that those factors stopped King David from sleeping with Bathsheba later on...)

How could David, who is depicted in the bible as the loyal yet mistreated servant of Saul (even as Saul undergoes a manhunt for him to kill him), break faith with the king and do such a thing? Why is Hollywood so stupid?

Or are they?

As I did research, I found out that the idea of a relationship between David and Ahinoam, while not explicitly stated in the text, is a possibility of interpretation and further shows the writer's engagement with the text.

There are seven mentions of Ahinoam in the Tanak. These seven mentions either refer to one woman named Ahinoam or to two. Ahinoam is called the wife of Saul once and then all of the following six times she is called David's wife. Let us look at these instances.

The first mention of Ahinoam—and the only reference to her as Saul's wife—is in 1 Samuel 14:50 amidst a brief section on Saul's genealogy and family. It states, "And the name of the woman(wife) of Saul [was] Ahino'am daughter of Ahima'az" (וְשֵׁם אֵשֶׁת שָׁאוּל אֲחִינֹעַם בַּת־אֲחִימָעַץ). Here, Ahinoam is called the daughter of a certain Ahima'az and Saul's wife. There are no mentions of any other wives of Saul, so Ahinoam may have been his only wife. (He also had a concubine named Rizpah, whom we will at another time.)

The second mention of Ahinoam is in 1 Samuel 25:43, after the story of Nabal. Nabal, whose name means "fool," was being protected by David while he was hiding from Saul and undergoing guerilla raids of neighboring areas. David was a cross between an rebel insurgent and a guerilla vigilante—not that those are too different! David had protected Nabal's flocks from others and yet Nabal gives David no indication of respect or reward in return. So David sets out with his three hundred armed men to teach Nabal a lesson. En route, Nabal's wife, Abigail, goes out to David and offers him clothing and food. David relents from his plan and returns to his hiding place. Then the text mentions that Nabal died. Upon Nabal's death, David comes and swoops Abigail into his arms and makes her his wife. "And Abigail hasted and she rose and she rode upon the donkey—and five of her lasses who went with her. And she went after the messengers of David—and she was to him as a woman(wife)" (וַתְּמַהֵ֞ר וַתָּ֣קָם אֲבִיגַ֗יִל וַתִּרְכַּב֙ עַֽל־הַחֲמֹ֔ור וְחָמֵשׁ֙ נַעֲרֹתֶ֔יהָ הַהֹלְכֹ֖ות לְרַגְלָ֑הּ וַתֵּ֗לֶךְ אַֽחֲרֵי֙ מַלְאֲכֵ֣י דָוִ֔ד וַתְּהִי־לֹ֖ו לְאִשָּֽׁה׃). Abigail becomes David's second wife, the first who was Mikal.

The next verse says, "And Ahinoam David took from Jezreel—indeed, the two of them were to him as women(wives)" (וְאֶת־אֲחִינֹ֛עַם לָקַ֥ח דָּוִ֖ד מִֽיִּזְרְעֶ֑אל וַתִּהְיֶ֛יןָ גַּֽם־שְׁתֵּיהֶ֥ן לֹ֖ו לְנָשִֽׁים׃ ס). Here we learn that after Abigail, David "takes" Ahinoam as his wife from the city of Jezreel.

Interestingly, the next verse shows retaliatory action upon King Saul's part. Saul takes David's first wife, Mikal, and give her to another. "And Saul gave Miykal his daughter, the woman(wife) of David, to Palti, the son of Layish who [is] from Gallim [Springs]" (וְשָׁא֗וּל נָתַ֛ן אֶת־מִיכַ֥ל בִּתֹּ֖ו אֵ֣שֶׁת דָּוִ֑ד לְפַלְטִ֥י בֶן־לַ֖יִשׁ אֲשֶׁ֥ר מִגַּלִּֽים׃). For whatever reason, Saul gives David's first wife Mikal to another man. What a jerk! I find it interesting that this event takes place immediately following David's taking of Ahinoam—whose name also happens to be the name of Saul's wife. Could it possibly be that David took Saul's wife as his own and so Saul, in retaliation, gave his daughter to another man?

Every following mention of Ahinoam in the bible is as David's wife. 1 Samuel 27:3 "And David dwelt with Achish at Gath, he and his men, every man with his household, [even] David with his two wives, Ahinoam the Jezreelitess, and Abigail the Carmelitess, Nabal's wife."

1 Samuel 30:5 "And David's two wives were taken captives, Ahinoam the Jezreelitess, and Abigail the wife of Nabal the Carmelite." (David goes to rescue them, by the way.)

2 Samuel 2:2 "So David went up thither, and his two wives also, Ahinoam the Jezreelitess, and Abigail Nabal's wife the Carmelite."

2 Samuel 3:2 "And unto David were sons born in Hebron: and his firstborn was Amnon, of Ahinoam the Jezreelitess..." - here, Ahinoam mothers David's son Amnon

And finally, 1 Chronicles 3:1, which is a retelling of all that happened in the books of Samuel and Kings: "Now these were the sons of David, which were born unto him in Hebron; the firstborn Amnon, of Ahinoam the Jezreelitess; the second Daniel, of Abigail the Carmelitess"

Every mention Ahinoam as David's wife is in reference to the city of Jezreel, apparently where she was born. The King James translates this as "Jezreelitess," that is, a woman of Jezreel. It could be that the biblical writer was seeking to distinguish the two Ahinoams—Ahinoam the daughter of Ahimaaz, Saul's wife, vs. Ahinoam the Jezreelitess, whom David took.

But is there any evidence that there was only one Ahinoam—Saul's queen, whom David took?

Yes.

While David is hiding from King Saul, Saul rages at his son Jonathan/Yonatan for supporting David. Saul yells at his son: "Son of a perverted, rebellious woman! Did not I know that you had chosen the son of Jesse to your shame and to the shame of your mother's nakedness!" 1 Samuel 20:30 (בֶּֽן־נַעֲוַ֖ת הַמַּרְדּ֑וּת הֲלֹ֣וא יָדַ֗עְתִּי כִּֽי־בֹחֵ֤ר אַתָּה֙ לְבֶן־יִשַׁ֔י לְבָ֨שְׁתְּךָ֔ וּלְבֹ֖שֶׁת עֶרְוַ֥ת אִמֶּֽךָ׃). It is not perfectly clear what Saul is referring to, but it seems that some sexual sin is the point. The fact that he calls his wife "perverted" and the reference to his mother's "nakedness" (which is a euphemism for the pudenda, or female genitalia) seems to indicate that Ahinoam may have been promiscuous, which could refer to a liason between her and David. Saul is obviously angry that Yonatan is in league with the rogue David and that he "chose" him over his own father. Alternately, this verse could have Saul angry at his son for engaging in a potential homoerotic relationship with David (whether it actually happened or Saul thinks it did). The first line can read, "Son of perverted rebelliousness!" in the abstract, in which case Saul is calling Yonatan perverted for shamefully "choosing" David and thereby violating his mother's nakedness, that is, the means by which Yonatan entered the world. This verse can be read as a reference to Ahinoam's adultery, Yonatan's (alleged) homosexual relationship with David, or Yonatan's political support of David instead of his father. All three are possible interpretations.

Another point that may support David's taking Saul's wife is a statement that the prophet Nathan makes to the now-King David after he commits adultery with Bathsheba. Nathan tells King David that God has given King Saul's house and wives into his possession: "And I gave to you the house of your master and the women(wives) of your master into your bosom—and I gave to you the house of Yisra'el and Y'hudah. And if that [had been too] little, I [would have] added to you such and such things" (2 Samuel 12:8 וָאֶתְּנָ֨ה לְךָ֜ אֶת־בֵּ֣ית אֲדֹנֶ֗יךָ וְאֶת־נְשֵׁ֤י אֲדֹנֶ֨יךָ֙ בְּחֵיקֶ֔ךָ וָאֶתְּנָ֣ה לְךָ֔ אֶת־בֵּ֥ית יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל וִֽיהוּדָ֑ה וְאִ֨ם־מְעָ֔ט וְאֹסִ֥פָה לְּךָ֖ כָּהֵ֥נָּה וְכָהֵֽנָּה׃). Nathan tells David that God gave David everything he wanted—the king's house, the king's harem, and the kingdoms of Yisra'el and Y'hudah, and if that wasn't enough, he would have provided more. It is interesting the reference to "thy master's wives" because, when David was enthroned after Saul's death, there is no mention of David taking Saul's harem. We are left with the possibility that David preemptively took Saul's wife before his death.

The Jewish Women's Archive states that David's taking of Queen Ahinoam was a political statement to the effect that Saul was in decline. "[The scholars] Levenson and Halpern argue that David’s marriage to Ahinoam constituted a claim to Saul’s throne (see Absalom’s actions in 2 Sam 16:22). Perhaps David, like other kings who appropriated the harems of their predecessors or rivals, strengthened his claim to the throne in this way." Since God had already spurned Saul and chose David, David's action may have been a symbolic enactment of that divine choice. Saul was on the way out, so this adultery can be justified.

But can it really? The sins recorded in the bible do not make God or the Bible sinful—the bible simply describes what people do. Adultery was still sinful, but David went ahead and committed it with Bathsheba, so it is not inconceivable that David took Queen Ahinoam.

But this is all speculation. What it shows, however, is that the makers of Of Kings and Prophets are thoughtfully engaging the biblical text, even if it, unfortunately, goes against our tastes and values.

Sources:

Levenson, John D., and Baruch Halpern. “The Political Import of David’s Marriages.” Journal of Biblical Literature 99 (1980): 507–18.

Schearing, Linda. "Ahinoam: Bible." Jewish Women: A Comprehensive Historical Encyclopedia. 1 March 2009. Jewish Women's Archive. (Viewed on March 24, 2016) .

Monday, December 14, 2015

Hebrew Gospel of Matthew?

Some scholars maintain that idea of a Semitic origin to the Gospel of Matthew is preposterous. Nevertheless, here I will delineate several features of the Gospel of Matthew in Greek that lends credibility to the idea that it is was originally written in Hebrew.

1. First is the idea of biblical numerology, or gematria.

In the first chapter of Matthew's Gospel, the author employs a technique that would either only make sense in the Hebrew language or that would require his readers to immediately understand or know the Hebrew language. The author begins his book with the words, the book of the birth of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham (βιβλος γενεσεως ιησου χριστου υιου δαυιδ υιου αβρααμ, Biblos geneseōs Yēsou Xristou hiou David hiou Abraam). He then begins to recount Jesus' genealogy from the patriarch Avraham, through King David. Matthew divided the genealogy into three segments:

  1. The first segment is from Avraham to King David.
  2. The second segment is from King David to the deportation of Babylon (της μετοικεσιας βαβυλωνος, tēs metoikesias Babulónos).
  3. The final and third segment is from the deportation of Babylon to Jesus, who is called Christ (ο λεγομενος χριστος, ho legomenos Xristos).
After Matthew is done recounting the genealogy, he notes that each segment happens to have 14 generations.

1:17 Therefore all the generations from Abraam until David [were] 14 generations, and from David until the deportation of Babylon [were] 14 generations, and from the deportation of Babylon until the Christ [were] 14 generations. (πασαι ουν αι γενεαι απο αβρααμ εως δαυιδ γενεαι δεκατεσσαρες και απο δαυιδ εως της μετοικεσιας βαβυλωνος γενεαι δεκατεσσαρες και απο της μετοικεσιας βαβυλωνος εως του χριστου γενεαι δεκατεσσαρες, pasai oun hai geneai apo Abraam heōs David geneai deka-tessares (14) kai apo David eōs tēs metoikesias Babylónos geneai deka-tessares (14) kai apo tēs metoikesias Babylónos eōs tou xristou geneai deka-tessares)

I will argue that Matthew has some purpose for 14, that it is more than simply an antiquarian note. In fact, 14 is tremendously important, not just in the genealogy itself, but in the reason why Matthew incorporates the genealogy in the first place. Matthew needed to make sure that the three segments of the genealogy each had 14 generations.

What's so important about 14? Return to the first line: the book of the birth of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham. Matthew is, obviously, trying to show that Jesus is the descendant of David and hence a candidate for the messianic redemption. But Matthew is not just doing so through the genealogical descent, he is also using gematria.

In Hebrew, each letter of the alphabet has a numeric value. That is, if you wanted to write 1 in numeral form in Hebrew, you would write the first letter of the Hebrew alphabet, aleph. If you wanted to write the numeral 2 in Hebrew, you would write the second letter of the Hebrew alphabet, bet.

  1. aleph א
  2. bet ב
  3. gimel ג
  4. daleth ד
  5. he ה
  6. waw ו
...and so on down the alphabet

In this genealogy, Matthew is using gematria on David's name in Hebrew. David's name in Hebrew is D-V-D (דוד), or Dalet-Waw-Dalet. Can you figure out the numerical value of that name? (Daleth = 4) + (Waw = 6) + (Daleth = 4). 4 + 6 + 4 = 14. David in Hebrew has the numerical value of 14! And Matthew's important number is 14! Basically, Matthew is saying that Jesus is David three times, or in other words, Jesus' fulfills David's kingly role thrice. Jesus is thrice David.

This feature is only apparent in the Hebrew language, in Greek it does not work. This fact means that Matthew wrote in the Hebrew language or that he wrote in another language but intended his audience to understand this Hebrew-language gematria. As to the latter possibility, it would be unlikely that Matthew would have written in another language (Greek) and would have intended his audience to understand Hebrew. If they understood Hebrew, he might as well have written in Hebrew. Since it would have been unhelpful to write in Greek—the gematria would have been lost—it appears that the former option is more likely. The gematria is only present in the Hebrew, and therefore it is more likely that he wrote in Hebrew.


2. The second line of evidence for an Hebraic autograph of Matthew is the Gospel's introduction of the name Jesus.

Matthew introduces Jesus' name first in the genealogy, and then in the narrative recounts how the messenger, or angel, of the lord appeared to Joseph in a dream and told him that Mary was having a child from holy spirit (no definite article, interestingly enough). The angel tells Joseph:

v. 20 Yosef, son of David, do not fear to take Miryam, your wife, for the thing in her, begotten out of spirit, is holy. (ιωσηφ υιος δαυιδ μη φοβηθης παραλαβειν μαριαν την γυναικα σου το γαρ εν αυτη γεννηθεν εκ πνευματος εστιν αγιου) Yōsēf, huios David, mé phobētés paralabein Marian tēn gunaika sou to gar en auté gennēten ek pneumatos, estin hagiou.

v. 21 She will give birth to a son, and you shall call his name Yesous, for he himself shall save his people from their sins. (τεξεται δε υιον και καλεσεις το ονομα αυτου ιησουν αυτος γαρ σωσει τον λαον αυτου απο των αμαρτιων αυτων) Texetai de huion kai kaleseis to onoma autou Yēsoun, autos gar sōsei ton laon autou apo tōn hamartian autōn.

That's all well and good until you realize that Yesous or Iesous has absolutely no meaning in the Greek language. (In Greek, if an i, or iota, appears at the beginning of a word followed by a vowel, it ends up making a /y/ sound; hence why Iesous in Greek is pronounced Yesous.) It is clear from the grammatical construction that the angel intends the statement to be an explanation of the child's name (you shall name him...because he will...). There is something about that name that the angel intends to connect with the following statement.

People who are familiar with the Messianic movement will know that Jesus' Hebrew name is Yeshua. Such people may also know that Yeshua is the Aramaic shortened form of the Hebrew Yehoshua (from whence we derive Joshua). In Hebrew, the Yeho- prefix, as in Yehoshua, refers to Yah, the god of the Israelites. Shua means salvation, and so Yehoshua means Yah is salvation. Since Yeshua is a shortened form of Yehoshua, Yeshua also means Yah is salvation.

In Hebrew, the angelic announcement would have an alliteration on the name of Yeshua. One Hebrew version, the Hebrew version of Delitzsch, translates it thus:

וְהִיא יֹלֶדֶת בֵּן וְקָרָאתָ אֶת־שְׁמוֹ יֵשׁוּעַ כִּי הוּא יוֹשִׁיעַ אֶת־עַמּוֹ מֵחַטֹּאתֵיהֶם
v'hi yoledet v'qarata et-shemó Yeshuá, ki hu yoshia et-amó me-ḥato'teihem

In English transliteration, the angel says: you shall his name, Yeshua, ki hu yoshia (...Jesus, because he will save...).

Notice the alliteration. In the explanations of name in the Book of Genesis, one will find a lot of these explanatory alliterations. If we were to reproduce this alliteration into English it could be something like:

You shall call his name Savior, because he will save...

This alliteration is significant, because it links the name (Yeshua) with the act (yoshia). However, this alliteration, which the author intended, is not found in the Greek. The alliteration is only found in Hebrew, which is another reason why it is more likely that Matthew wrote in Hebrew.

The scholar and poet Willis Barnstone offers this comment on the angel's introduction of Jesus' name:

The naming of the infant messiah as Jesus, Iesous in the Greek, is followed by the reason for naming Jesus, explaining that the name means he will save. But the name Jesus in the Greek, Iesous (Ἱησοῡς), has no meaning in the Greek other than being a transliteration of the Hebrew Yeshua, from Yehoshua, which does mean Yahweh saves. This passage suggests either an earlier text in the Hebrew or the Aramaic or that the author of the Greek Matthew was a Greek- and Hebrew-speaking who had in mind the Hebrew or Aramaic name Yeshua or Yehoshua for the salvific lord and expected the readers or listeners to understand the name of the salvific lord in Hebrew embedded in the name Yeshua or Yehoshua. There seems to be no other explanation for attributing he will save to a Greek name which itself is meaningless.

Thus writes Barnstone. As far as we can tell, either Matthew wrote in Hebrew or he was a bilingual Jew who thought in Hebrew, wrote in Greek and expected his readers to do the same. While the latter would be fun, the former seems to be more likely.

Sunday, November 8, 2015

The Origins of the Jewish People

  1. Adam
    --> humanity
  2. Sheth
  3. Enosh
  4. Keinan
  5. Mahalal'el
  6. Yered
  7. Hanokh
  8. Methushelach
  9. Lamech
  10. Noach
    1. Cham
    2. Yefet
    3. Shem
      --> Shemites (Semites)

  11. Arpakhshad
  12. Shelach
  13. 'Ever
    --> 'Evri, or Hebrews
  14. Peleg
  15. Re'u
  16. S'erug
  17. Nachor
  18. Terach
  19. Avram aka Avraham --> father of the monotheistic, Abrahamaic religions
    1. Yishma'el --> Ismhaelites aka Arabs
    2. Yitz'chak (Isaac)
  20. Yaakov (Jacob) aka Yisra'el (Israel)
    --> Israelites

Wednesday, September 23, 2015

On what to call the 'Bible'

"Bible" refers to the various collections of authoritative texts for the Christian and Jewish communities. The word itself entered Middle English during the middle ages from the Old French language, deriving from ecclesiastical Latin biblia.

Latin biblia was itself derived from Greek plural βιβλια biblia ‘books,’ from Greek singular βιβλιον biblion ‘book,’ which was originally a diminutive of βιβλος biblos ‘papyrus, scroll,’ which came from a word of unknown Semitic origin.

So, from an etymological perspective, bible means "papyrus books." Many people forget that the word bible is a plural - books. So a better translation for bible might be "collection," "anthology," or "library." I like to read the books, I like to read the library, I like to read the anthology, or the collection.

But then the question arises: to which books or to which library or collection are you referring?

Well, I respond, I am referring to the Judaeo-Christian books.

There are many books in the world. And there are many sacred books, books considered holy and authoritative to given religious communities.

So just saying the books to refer to what we now call the Bible might be confusing to some. Are you referring to the Buddhist books, or the Hindu books, or the Celtic books, or to all the books of the world?

So now we have to modify these books with a qualifier. Jewish books. Christian books. But how are we to separate books written by Jews and Christians nowadays from the sacred books used by Jews and Christians?

Jewish sacred text and Christian sacred text is clumsy, but could work. Scholars call the Jewish sacred text the Hebrew Scriptures or the Hebrew Bible. But there is a problem: not everything in the Jewish sacred text is written in Hebrew, so calling it the Hebrew Scriptures is misleading. True, most of it is written in Hebrew, but large sections (Genesis 31:47; Jeremiah 10:10-11; Daniel 2:4 - 7:28; Ezra 4:8 - 6:18, 7:12-26) are written in Aramaic, not Hebrew. Should we call it the Hebrew/Aramaic Scriptures?

And calling it the Jewish Scriptures, as some do, is problematic too, because the writings which are commonly called the New Testament were also written by Jews, so the New Testament writings deserve to be called the Jewish Scriptures just as much as the "old testament" writings do.

Also, restricting the term Hebrew Scriptures to the "old testament" also neglects the fact that scholars believe that many books of the new testament were written in Hebrew too (e.g., the Gospel of Matthew).

So far, we have learned that calling it the Hebrew Scriptures overlooks the Aramaic text, and that both what are called the old testament and the new testament equally deserve the titles Hebrew Scriptures and Jewish Scriptures, as both were written by Jews and both had parts written in Hebrew.

So what are we to call the old and the new testaments?

I suggest we use the Hebrew terms for them. (Gasp! What a surprise that I am saying this!)

The Hebrew term for the "old testament" is Tanak, the English transliteration of the Hebrew acronym תַּנַ"ךְ‎.

תַּנַ"ךְ is an acronym for the three divisions of the "old testament":

  1. ת, the first letter of תּוֹרָה, torah, which means "teaching," "direction," "orientation," or "instruction"
  2. נ, the first letter of נְבִיאִים, Nəḇî'îm, which means "prophets"
  3. כ, the first letter of כְּתוּבִים, Kəṯûḇîm, which means "writings"
Thus, combining T and N and K and filling in with some vowels gives one TaNaK. Sometimes you might see it vocalized as Tenak or Tenakh or Tenach.

Thus, our 'new' word for the old testament is Tanak - which sounds cooler anyway.

How about the "new testament"?

In Hebrew, the new testament is called the בְרִית חֲדָשָׁה, or berith khadashah.

Like the Tanak, the בְרִית חֲדָשָׁה too has three divisions:
  1. בְּשׂוֹרָת הַגְּאֻלָּה, besorath hageulah, the "good news of redemption," or the four gospels and Acts = five books
  2. הִתְגַּלּוּת, hithgaluth, "unveiling" or "uncovering," aka the Revelation, comparable to the Prophets in Tanak
  3. אִגְּרוֹת, 'iggeroth, "letters," or epistles, comparable to the Writings in Tanak
בְרִית means a "covenant."

And חֲדָשָׁה, well that will take some more time to explain. חֲדָשָׁה is the feminine singular form of the masculine singular adjective חָדָשׁ, khadash.

חָדָשׁ derives from the noun חֹ֫דֶשׁ, khodesh. חֹ֫דֶשׁ means roughly "new moon" or "month."

But the "true" meaning is found in the verb which all these words are related to: חָדַשׁ, khadash.

חָדַשׁ means to "repair" or to "renew" or to "restore," or to make new or even to refresh or make fresh.

The Hebrews thought symbolically. They called the moon חֹ֫דֶשׁ because the new moon is always restored or renewed to its previous location. חָדַשׁ, then, means to bring back to a prior state.

So if a בְרִית, a covenant, is brought back to a prior state, what does that make it?

Well it makes the covenant a renewed covenant, or a restored, or even a refreshed covenant. And that's what the new testament is.

It's a renewed covenant. A covenant that went through a development and came back to its original state. It's not necessarily a "new" covenant, but a restored covenant. A refreshed covenant.

G-d renewed, restored, refreshed his covenant. It's not a completely new covenant. It's the same "old" covenant restored, refreshed, and renewed. It's actually going back in time and bringing the past to the present. The new covenant is actually an old covenant.

The covenant was: I will be your god and you will be my people, and I will protect you and deliver you. Now walk in my statutes and keep my commandments and worship Me only.

The covenant is: I will be your god and you will be my people, and I will protect you and deliver you. Now walk in my statutes and keep my commandments and worship Me only.

The covenant was just for the people of Israel and to any aliens or strangers who might reside in their encampments. But with the restored covenant, G-d adds gentiles to the mix. In the restoration of the world, returning to as it was supposed to be, not only Jews but also gentiles will worship G-d. Through the mashiakh, G-d will bring all peoples back to himself, to enjoy a period of peace and shalom.

So maybe, in light of that restoration, we should call the "Bible" by its proper name: Tanak and B'rit Khadashah. One bible. Two mirrors reflecting that one truth, in three divisions each.

Sunday, September 6, 2015

Jesus, the Woman at the Well, and John's Gospel

The story recorded in the Gospel of Yokhannon (John) about Yeshua's interaction with the woman from Shomron (Samaria) is one of my favorite encounters recorded in the Gospels. Not only is the encounter touching and tender, but it is also intriguing from a cultural, linguistic, and religious point of view. In fact, despite Yeshua's compassionate treatment of the woman, it seems that they do experience a sort of standoff between each other. To see this standoff, follow the narrative:

When Yeshua mentions that he possesses the mayim khayim (living water in Hebrew; מַיָא חַיֵא, maya khaye in Aramaic
), the Shomroni woman eagerly asks that he give this water to her, so that she won't be thirsty again. Then Yeshua tells her to get her husband and bring him.

She answered and said to him, "I have no husband."

And then Yeshua says to her,
You are right to say, "I have no husband."
You have had five husbands and the one
you have now
is not your husband.
What you have spoke is the truth.
Touche. That hurts.

Then the woman realizes that Yeshua is a prophet and tries to take the focus of the conversation away from herself (feeling guilty at this point, undoubtedly) and onto a certain theological squabble that the Jews and Samaritans had at this time in history.

First, a quick history of the relationship between the two groups. Essentially, the Samaritans (Shomronim in Hebrew) were part of those Israelites who remained in the land of Israel (the northern half) when the Assyrians deported many of the Judaeans in 722 BCE. The Shomronim claim that they are direct descendants of the tribes of Ephraim and Manasseh. Shomroni historiography reports that there was a schism in the days of Eli the high priest, and that one part of the people stayed loyal to Eli (who became the Samaritans), and the other part went astray and worshipped other gods. Needless to say, saying that most of the Jews don't have the truth is a theological affront. Therefore, the Jews and Samaritans have always been claiming that each other is wrong and that they themselves have the truth. I suppose the relationship between Jews and Samaritans (who still exist to this day, with a population of around 700 people) resembles the relationship between Protestant Christians and Catholic Christians - originally the same, yet now strongly differentiated into rival factions with major theological differences.

The Shomronim claim that their mountain, Mount Gerizim, is the mountain upon which God wants people to worship. In fact, according to them, Eli built a temple there in his day. The Jews, obviously, claim that Zion is God's mountain and there they have built the Jerusalem temple. Additionally, the Shomronim even have their own version of the Torah, which is quite different in places from the Jewish Torah, and reject anything beyond these five books of Mosheh. So needless to say, the relationship between Jews and Samaritans is tense, especially more so in the first century.

And it is toward these differences that the woman at the well redirects the conversation, away from herself.
My lord, I see that you are a prophet. Our fathers worshipped on this mountain [Mount Gerizim], but you say Yerushalayim is the place where we must worship.
The woman tries to incite a theological argument. Yeshua responds,
Believe me, woman, the hour is coming
when not on this mountain
nor in Yerushalayim will you worship the father.
You worship what you do not know.
We worship what we do know
since salvation is from the Jews.
But the hour is coming and is it now
when the true worshippers will worship the father
in spirit and truth,
for the father seeks such people to worship him.
God is spirit
and those worshipping him must worship him
in spirit and truth.
Can you say intolerant? Yeshua basically says to the girl that the Samaritans don't even know how to worship God correctly. But he couches the correction with compassion, claiming that in a certain time, God won't care how you worship him or who worships him, as long as they worship him "in spirit and truth" (Complete Jewish Bible: "spiritually and truly). It won't matter if you're Jewish, Samaritan, or whatever. As long as you worship the father in spirit and truth, then God won't care who or how it is. Form (liturgy, order, etc.) will be replaced with heart - intention. In that day, all who call upon the name of YHWH shall be saved. This sentiment is also echoed in Rabbi Sha'ul's statement in his epistles thirty years later that, "in messiah, there is neither Jew nor Gentile, male nor female; for you are all one in messiah." Yeshua was evidently speaking of the messianic age, which he was inaugurating with his life's work.

The woman responds to the effect that she'll ponder what Yeshua has told her, almost dismissing him to the effect that she can't decide now but that she'll consider it at a later time.
"I know that messiah is coming (the one who has been called christ). When he comes, he will declare to us all."
The woman dismisses Yeshua with the statement that when messiah comes, everyone will know the truth.

Then Yeshua is like, um, just look at me.

Yeshua says to her, ἐγώ εἰμι ὁ λαλῶν σοι.
I, he who is speaking to you, am.
Yeshua lets her know that she is speaking to none other than the messiah himself. In the Greek, Yeshua only says ἐγώ εἰμι, one of the fabled "I am" sayings of Jesus supposedly asserting his divinity, but which merely assert, if anything, his 'messianity.' In context, ἐγώ εἰμι means not, "I am" as in the One who exists eternally without beginning or end, but rather, "I am the person you are talking about," or, as most modern translations render it, "I am he" (i.e., in this context, the messiah). Even the blind beggar whom Yeshua heals in chapter 9 says ἐγώ εἰμι, in context meaning, "I am the man you are looking for." Obviously, the blind man was not making a claim to deity.

Eventually, the woman at the well does believe that Yeshua is messiah and goes on to tell everyone else in the town of Shekhem, who also come out to listen to him and subsequently believe in him.

Anyways, I love the narrative drama in this encounter. The years of tension and hatred are boiling beneath the surface, and it takes a stubborn woman and an itinerant carpenter and rabbi to ease it. This passage is also eye-opening from a grammatical perspective. I wish to focus on verse 25, the woman's statement that she knows messiah is coming.

In the Greek, it reads:
(John 4:25 MGNT) λέγει αὐτῷ ἡ γυνή οἶδα ὅτι Μεσσίας ἔρχεται ὁ λεγόμενος Χριστός ὅταν ἔλθῃ ἐκεῖνος ἀναγγελεῖ ἡμῖν ἅπαντα
legei auto hay gunay oida hoti messias erkhetai ho legomenos khristos hotan elthay ekeinos anangelei haymin hapanta.
The woman says to him, "I know that messiah is coming, he who has been called christ. When this man comes, he will announce everything to us."
The interesting thing is the line ὁ λεγόμενος Χριστός, "he who has been called christ." What is extraordinarily interesting is that the woman, in the Greek text, uses both the Hebraic and Greek words to reference the messiah. First, the woman uses the Hebraic word Μεσσίας (messiah) to reference the messiah, and then uses the Greek word Χριστός (Christ), which also means messiah. The woman, then, uses two words for messiah that are equivalent in meaning, although different in etymology — one derived from the Greek and one derived from the Hebrew

Μεσσίας is a transliteration into Greek of a Hebrew word, מָשִׁיחַ, mashiakh, that means "anointed (one)." A מָשִׁיחַ is a person that God has anointed with oil (i.e., consecrated or chosen) for a specific task or mission. In the Hebrew Scriptures, the Tanakh, מָשִׁיחַ variously describes Israelite kings, Israelite high priests, a future prince (in Daniel 9:25f), the Hebrew patriarchs, and the Persian prince Cyrus, whom God used in his plan to bring back the Jews from Babylon to Israel. In summary, Μεσσίας is a transliteration into Greek letters of the Hebrew word meaning "anointed."

Now Χριστός, on the other hand, is the native Greek word for the same concept. Χριστός also means "anointed." Χριστός is used in the Greek-language translation of the Tanakh (that is, the Septuagint, abbreviated by scholars as LXX - a reference to the seventy scholars that translated it, according to legend) and in the New Covenant texts. Χριστός in the plays of the Greek playwrights Aeschylus and Euripedes refers to that which is rubbed on, that is, ointment or salve. When one anoints someone with oil, they rub the oil over them, so Χριστός means anointed. In summary, Χριστός is the Greek word that means "anointed."

So Χριστός, not the transliteration Μεσσίας, is the word that a Greek-speaker would use for the messiah. If the woman and Yeshua both spoke Greek, she would not have said, "I know that the Μεσσίας is coming, he who has been called Χριστός." She is basically repeating herself, in two different languages. If she spoke Greek, there would have been no reason to use Μεσσίας and then use Χριστός. She would have just used Χριστός. This doubling of meaning suggests, rather, that the Greek explanation with is not original to the woman, but is an authorial or scribal gloss. In other words, the woman never said Χριστός - that word was added later by the author or the scribe so that the Greek-speaking reading audience would know what Μεσσίας, a Hebraic word, meant.

Moreover, this doubling of terms suggests that the evangelist (the gospel-writer) did not write in Greek, unless he were merely recording the woman's words. But if he were recording her words, the only reason to not use Χριστός in her mouth would be for stylistic effect. Surely, the woman did not say, "οἶδα ὅτι Μεσσίας ἔρχεται ὁ λεγόμενος Χριστός" (I know that Messiah, the one called christ, is coming)! Are we expected to believe that the woman said, in her language, "I know that messiah is coming, he who has been called christ"??? The woman, who is not a Greek-speaker, would not have explained to Yeshua what Μεσσίας means, much more less in a language that neither of them knew (namely, Greek). Yeshua and the woman did not know what a christ was, as they did not speak Greek. The only option is that ὁ λεγόμενος Χριστός is not what the woman spoke to Yeshua. Rather, those words are a scribal gloss, either by the evangelist himself or a later scribe.

Μεσσίας is used in the New Covenant scriptures only twice, both in John, one of them being here. The other is in the first chapter of Yokhannon's gospel, when Yeshua is entering his ministry. One of the talmidim (students, learners) of Yokhannon the immerser (aka John the Baptist/Baptizer) meets Yeshua and goes to tell his brother, who happens to be none other than Shimon Kefa (Simon Peter).

"First," the writer tells us, "he finds his own brother Shimon and says to him, 'We have found the messiah' (which is, having been translated, 'christ')."
(John 1:41 MGNT) εὑρίσκει οὗτος πρῶτον τὸν ἀδελφὸν τὸν ἴδιον Σίμωνα καὶ λέγει αὐτῷ εὑρήκαμεν τὸν Μεσσίαν ὅ ἐστιν μεθερμηνευόμενον Χριστός

Here, we have another gloss, obviously not spoken by Shimon, a Jew, to his brother, both of whom spoke Aramaic and would have known some Hebrew from synagogue, but certainly not Greek. The words ὅ ἐστιν μεθερμηνευόμενον Χριστός, explaining in Greek the meaning of "messiah," were added by the writer or another scribe.

Another gloss of a like nature in the same chapter suggests that the gospel-writer himself did not originally write the gospel in Greek.

Just beforehand, the talmidim of Yokhannon the immerser ran after Yeshua and ask him where he is staying the night.
(John 1:38 MGNT) στραφεὶς δὲ ὁ Ἰησοῦς καὶ θεασάμενος αὐτοὺς ἀκολουθοῦντας λέγει αὐτοῖς τί ζητεῖτε οἱ δὲ εἶπαν αὐτῷ ῥαββί ὃ λέγεται μεθερμηνευόμενον διδάσκαλε ποῦ μένεις 
And having turned and having seen those following him, Jesus says to them, "What are you seeking?"
And they said to him, "Rabbi! — which says, having been translated, 'teacher!' — where are you staying?"
Again, are we to believe that these Jewish talmidim interjected a translation into Greek of rabbi while speaking to a rabbi? Did Rabbi Yeshua not know what a rabbi was? Did he not know that a rabbi was a teacher? Obviously the words ὃ λέγεται μεθερμηνευόμενον διδάσκαλε are a scribal or authorial gloss.

A final instance is in verse 42, where Yeshua gives to Shimon the appellation "Peter."
(John 1:42 MGNT) ἤγαγεν αὐτὸν πρὸς τὸν Ἰησοῦν ἐμβλέψας αὐτῷ ὁ Ἰησοῦς εἶπεν σὺ εἶ Σίμων ὁ υἱὸς Ἰωάννου σὺ κληθήσῃ Κηφᾶς ὃ ἑρμηνεύεται Πέτρος.
And he led him to Jesus. Having looked at him, Jesus said, "You are Shimon, the son of Yokhannon. You shall be called Kefa" — which is interpreted, "peter."
In his native tongue, Yeshua calls Shimon Kefa, which is the Aramaic word for stone or rock. Similarly, Greek Πέτρος means stone or rock. Are we to expect that Yeshua, in their native Aramaic, calls Shimon a "stone," and then, to make sure he got the message, also calls him a "stone" in Greek, a language which they did not speak? Surely, Yeshua renamed Shimon "rock" or "stone" in their native Aramaic, and the Greek explanation is a later gloss for a Greek-speaking audience.

These examples serve to show some of the many instances where Yokhannon's gospel (and the other gospels) retains spoken Hebrew or Aramaic terms and then renders them into Greek as an explanatory gloss for Greek-speaking readers.

Now the question remains, why did the author retain these Hebraic and Aramaic terms in the first place? Why not simply use the Greek word, since they are writing the rest of the sentences in Greek?

Obviously, as I stated above, these glosses could be stylistic elements included by the author. Sort of like local color or William Faulkner or Mark Twain writing in "Black" English (or more academically, "African American Vernacular English"). But, for being supposedly literary effects, these glosses seem awfully stilted ("which, having been translated, means...").

On the other hand, it would make more sense that Yokhannon wrote his gospel in Aramaic and that a later scribe added these glossal emendations when the gospel was translated into Greek.

For evidence of an Aramaic primacy for Yokhannon, compare the Gospel as rendered in Aramaic with the Gospel as rendered in Hebrew.

John 1:38 in the ancient Aramaic/Syriac text does not have the gloss ῥαββί ὃ λέγεται μεθερμηνευόμενον διδάσκαλε (...rabbi! — which says, having been translated, 'teacher!'). Instead, the Aramaic text simply has רַבַּן, rabban, without any Greek gloss.

However, the modern Hebrew translation of the Society for Distributing Hebrew Scriptures has רַבִּי אֲשֶׁר יֵאָמֵר מוֹרִי, "...rabbi — which says, 'my teacher!'" Professor Franz Delitzsch's modern Hebrew translation, however, omits the scribal gloss.

John 1:41 in the ancient Aramaic/Syriac text reads simply, without a gloss, אֵשׁכַּחנָיהי לַמשִׁיחָא "we have found the messiah." (In Aramaic messiah is mashikha; in Hebrew it is mashiakh.)

In the modern Hebrew translation, it is, מָצָאנוּ אֶת־הַמָּשִׁיחַ אֲשֶׁר בִּלְשׁוֹן יָוָן כְּרִיסְטוֹס, "we have found the mashiakh, which, in the Greek tongue, is Keristos." The Hebrew translation is trying to transliterate Greek Χριστός into Hebrew as כְּרִיסְטוֹס, keristos. How barbaric! Delitzsch, in his Hebrew translation, omits the scribal gloss.

John 1:42 in the ancient Aramaic/Syriac text omits the gloss, reading, תֵּתקרֵא כּאִפָא, "you shall be called Kifa."

The Society Hebrew translation reads, לְךָ יִקָּרֵא כֵיפָא וּבִלְשׁוֹן יָוָן פֶּטְרוֹס, "and to you it shall be called Keifa, and in the Greek tongue, Petros." Delitzsch renders it לְךָ יִקָּרֵא כֵּיפָא וְהוּא בִיוָנִית פֶּטְרוֹס, "and to you shall be called Keifa and it, in Greek, is Petros."

John 4:25 in the ancient Aramaic/Syriac texts also omits the gloss, reading דַּמשִׁיחָא, mashikha.

The Society Hebrew translation reads, מָשִׁיחַ הַנִּקְרָא כְרִיסְטוֹס, "mashiakh, called keristos." Similarly, Delitzsch too keeps the gloss, הַמָּשִׁיחַ אֲשֶׁר יִקָּרֵא לוֹ כְּרִיסְטוֹס, "mashiakh, which is called to him keristos."

The pattern is striking. The ancient Aramaic and Syriac texts uniformly do not render the glosses, simply omitting them. But the Hebrew translations alternately render or omit the glosses — Delitzsch renders two of them and omits the other two, while the Society for Distributing Hebrew Scriptures translation always renders the glosses in its own peculiar way into Hebrew.

The conclusion? There are two options. (a) Somewhere along the line, the Aramaic scribes omitted the glosses when they were translating the Gospel of Yokhannon into Aramaic. (b) The Gospel of Yokhannon was originally written in Aramaic, and the glosses were added when it was translated into Greek. The answer is up to you, the reader. Maybe by the time we are worshiping the father in spirit and truth we will have found the answer.

Sources

The English translation is predominantly taken from Willis Barnstone, The Restored New Testament: A New Translation with Commentary, Including the Gnostic Gospels Thomas, Mary, and Judas (New York: Norton, 2009), which, besides translating noncanonical gospels, is a wonderful and innovative translation of the Greek, rendering the names in a more Hebraic form and putting most of Yeshua's speech, the epistles, and the Apocalypse into poetic verse.

The Hebrew translations used were The New Testament in Hebrew and English (Middlesex, Society for Distributing Hebrew Scriptures, n.d.); also Franz Delitzsch, Hebrew New Testament, originally published Leipzig, 1877.

The Aramaic text is taken from the Peshitta NT online, http://www.dukhrana.com/peshitta, which makes use of the Peshitta NT published by the British and Foreign Bible Society in 1905/1920.

Saturday, July 25, 2015

Yeshayahu (Isaiah) 45:23

A translation of Yeshayahu 45:23 that I did today. Rabbi Sha’ul quoted it in his epistle to the Romans, 14:11, and it is also alluded to in the epistle to the Philippians, 2:10f, where Sha’ul applies it to Yeshua.

...I am ‘ēl, and (there is) nothing besides [or, nothing still, or, nothing else].
By me, I have sworn; a righteous word goes forth from my lips and it shall not return!
Because, to me, every knee, bow!
(To me,) every tongue, swear!